How are Tariffs Impacting the Skilled Trades?

Tariffs: A Short-Term Sting for Long-Term Gains

For Red, White, and Blue-collar’s second article, our CEO Rich dives into the pros, cons, and likely outcomes of tariffs. But first, as always, let’s remember that we aren’t here to pick sides or wave our Red or Blue flags, but rather to focus on how these policies might shape our daily work, labor market, and the industry we love.

Tariffs often get a bad rap. The moment they’re announced, headlines scream about rising prices, and consumers brace for the inevitable hit to their wallets. It’s true, tariffs can increase costs in the short term. But zoom out a bit, and the picture changes. Over the long haul, tariffs have the potential to spark job creation, boost government revenue, and reshape trade in ways that benefit domestic economies.

Much of the current headlines and “political talking heads” these days are comparing the current tariffs to the late 1800s and the Hoover Administration. Let me just say, Trump is not Herbert Hoover and today’s economy is drastically different than that of the 1920s and 30s. Now that this is settled, let’s break it down.

The Short-Term Pinch

When a country slaps tariffs on imported goods, higher prices are an immediate concern. Take steel, for example. If a 25% tariff gets tacked onto foreign steel, manufacturers who rely on it—think carmakers or construction firms – face higher input costs. They either eat the loss (unlikely) or pass it on to consumers (more likely). Once current inventory has been depleted, your new car or that kitchen remodel costs a bit more (i.e. 25%). Economists call this the “deadweight loss”, a temporary inefficiency where prices rise without an immediate upside. Thankfully, deadweight is not traditionally inflationary as it is a one-time price increase.

Data backs this up. When the U.S. imposed tariffs on Chinese goods in 2018, studies from the National Bureau of Economic Research found that American consumers and businesses bore over $40 billion in annual costs. Prices for things like electronics and clothing ticked up almost overnight. It’s not hard to see why people grumble.

The Long-Term Payoff: Jobs

But here’s where the story shifts, and of course I am most focused. Tariffs aren’t just about punishing imports, they’re about protecting and incentivizing domestic industries. When foreign goods get pricier, local producers get a chance to step up. That steel tariff? It might hurt carmakers at first, but it gives U.S. steel mills a lifeline. They ramp up production, hire more workers, and reinvest in their operations. Two great examples of this are recent domestic investment announcements by U.S. Steel/Nippon and General Motors.

Look at the U.S. steel industry post-2018 tariffs. The American Iron and Steel Institute (a great partner of BlueRecruit by the way) reported that steel production capacity increased by nearly 10% within a few years, and thousands of jobs were added. These industries stabilize and grow, the job gains compound, especially if paired with smart policies like tax incentives and workforce training.

Let’s look at manufacturing job creation since the election of President Trump versus that same period a year prior. Total manufacturing hiring is up an astounding 455% from November 6, 2024 to April 3, 2025. Put politics aside (as if that is even possible anymore), but numbers like these tell the real story and the likely driving factor for the current Administration’s actions.

Industry

Percent Increase in Hiring

(Nov 6, 2023 – April 3, 2024 vs Nov 6, 2024 – April 3, 2025)

Overall Skilled Trade Industries

323%

Energy & Utilities

482%

General Laborer

480%

Manufacturing

455%

Transportation & Warehousing

393%

*All hiring data sourced from the BlueRecruit marketplace.

Revenue Boost for Governments

Tariffs also mean cash. Every time an imported good gets taxed at the border, that money flows into government coffers. In 2019 alone, U.S. customs collected over $70 billion from tariffs, more than double the haul from a few years prior. That’s revenue that can fund infrastructure, education, or even tax cuts down the line. Critics argue it’s a tax on consumers, and they’re not entirely wrong in the short term. But in the long term, a stronger domestic economy, fueled by those jobs and industries, can offset the initial sting.

Better Trade, Not Just More Trade

The real win, though, is in trade dynamics. Tariffs can level the playing field. Countries that dump cheap, subsidized goods, like China with its state-backed steel, undercut fair competition. Tariffs push back, forcing trading partners to negotiate. The U.S.-China trade war led to the Phase One deal in 2020, where China pledged to buy more American goods. It wasn’t perfect, but it showed how tariffs can shift leverage.

Over decades, this can foster a trade environment where domestic industries aren’t just surviving, they’re thriving. Think of it like pruning a tree: a little pain now strengthens the roots for later growth. Countries that rely too heavily on cheap imports risk hollowing out their own production capacity. Tariffs, used wisely, can reverse that trend. New likely trade deals with countries like the United Kingdom, India, Japan, Vietnam, South Korea, and a renewed USMCA will foster growth and prosperity for generations both domestically and with our international partners.

The Catch

It’s not all rosy. Tariffs can backfire if they spark retaliation, think Canada and the EU hitting back with their own levies on U.S. exports like whiskey and Harley-Davidsons. Supply chains can also get messy, especially for complex goods like smartphones that rely on global parts. And if tariffs prop up inefficient industries too long, they can become a crutch rather than a catalyst. The key is execution: targeted tariffs, clear goals, and a plan to transition industries to self-sufficiency.

The Bottom Line

Yes, tariffs sting in the short term, higher prices are never fun. But the long-term view tells a different story. They are sparking job growth, filing government coffers, and pushing for both free and most importantly FAIR trade. It’s not about isolation; it’s about building resilience. So next time you hear “tariff” and wince, remember: a little friction today fuels a stronger tomorrow.